The 10 Best Hardware Stores in New York — 2026

We compared all 1625 hardware stores in New York on the data that matters: services offered, posted hours, and how easy each one is to reach. No pay-to-play — this ranking comes straight from the listings data, updated November 2026.

#1 · Greschlers' HardwareNew York

Mon–Fri 6:00am–4:00pm, Sat 7:30am–12:15pm, Sun Closed

(718) 499-3100 Website View listing

#2 · Water Mill Building SupplySouthampton Lumber

M-F 6:00AM - 5:00PM, SAT 7:00AM - 5:00PM, SUN Closed

(631) 726-4493 Website View listing

#3 · The Home DepotIthaca

Mon-Sat 6am-10pm, Sun 8am-8pm

(607) 272-1093 Website View listing

#4 · Mayer Paint & Hardware (Ace Hardware)Rochester

Mon-Fri 7:30am-7pm, Sat 8am-5pm, Sun 9am-3pm

(585) 288-7665 Website View listing

#5 · Fairbanks Lumber CoBronx Lumber

Mon–Fri 6:30am–4:00pm, Sat 6:30am–12:00pm

(718) 324-8358 Website View listing

#6 · Dolhof HardwareLyons Falls PropanePaintLumberFarm supplyFishing license

Sat 8am-5pm, Sun 9am-2pm

(315) 348-4066 Website View listing

#7 · Tractor Supply Co.Chester Farm supply

Mon-Sat 8am-9pm, Sun 9am-7pm

(845) 469-1732 Website View listing

#8 · S & V General SupplyNew York Key cuttingTool rentalPaintLumberScreen repairSharpeningGlass cuttingPlumbing

Mon–Sat 8:00am–6:00pm, Sun Closed

(212) 744-5706 Website View listing

#9 · Davies HardwarePoughkeepsie

Mon–Fri 7am–5pm, Sat 8am–2pm

(845) 452-6740 Website View listing

#10 · Fraser's HardwareMahopac PaintLumber

Mon - Sat 8:00 am - 5:00 pm, Sunday - 3:00 pm

(845) 628-0174 Website View listing

Run one of these businesses? You earned this spot — email contact@hardwarestoreatlas.com for your free “Top Hardware Stores in New York” badge to put on your site, and we’ll make sure your listing stays accurate.
How we rank: every listing earns points for listed services (key cutting, propane, tool rental, paint, lumber, farm supply, screen repair, small engine, sharpening, glass cutting, plumbing, fishing license), posted hours, and working contact details. The ranking is recalculated with every data update.